- Peyton Elizabeth Lee as Andi Mack
- Joshua Rush as Cyrus Goodman
- Sofia Wylie as Buffy Driscoll
- Asher Angel as Jonah Beck
- Lilan Bowden as Bex Mack
- Lauren Tom as Celia Mack
- Sienna Goines as Pat Driscoll
- Tim Shoemaker as Dad #1
- Clinton Brandt as Jefferson Player
- This episode aired 30 minutes earlier to accommodate the premiere of the Disney Channel Original Movie, Zombies.
- TJ's surname of Kippen is confirmed by a team mate.
- This title might be a play on from the episode, Were We Ever?.
- Buffy is reading the same nonexistent book, Girls Who Eat Candy, that Andi was reading during Friends Like These.
- Buffy's mother, Pat Driscoll, is seen for the first time in this episode. She has been deployed overseas for a long time.
| To view the We Were Never gallery, click here.